Hand-decorated cookies · Long Island
Cookies that taste as good as they look.
Vanilla sugar cookies, piped by hand in royal icing and made for your celebration. Pickup in Farmingville and South Huntington, serving Suffolk and Nassau.
Custom orders now booking about 6 to 8 weeks out
Limited time · one pickup day
The Holiday Pre-Sale
A small collection of designs, baked and decorated for one pickup day. Pick your favorites, choose your pickup spot, and pay by Zelle or Venmo within 24 hours. When the window closes, it closes.
Sample designs and prices for this preview.
Never miss a pre-sale.
Pre-sales open for about a week and designs sell out. Get a heads up the day ordering opens, for Valentine's, Easter, back to school, Halloween and the holidays.
Why people come back
Pretty is expected. Delicious is the point.
Plenty of decorated cookies look beautiful and taste like cardboard. Jen bakes one cookie, a vanilla sugar cookie, and puts as much care into how it tastes as into how it looks.
- One flavor, done rightVanilla sugar cookie. No gimmicks, just the one people ask for again.
- Royal icing, piped by handEvery detail is decorated one cookie at a time.
- Made for your dateBaked and decorated for your pickup, never pulled from a shelf.
“So many people tell me my cookies taste as good as they look. That's the part I'm proudest of.”Jen, founder
Custom orders
Your party, in cookie form.
Birthdays, showers, school events, company logos. Tell Jen your theme and colors, and she'll design a set that fits it.
- Birthdays
- Baby showers
- Bridal & weddings
- Holidays
- Teachers & schools
- Business & logo cookies
- Event planners
- Local organizations
How it works
- Send your requestAt least two weeks before your date. It takes about two minutes.
- Jen texts youTo talk through design, colors and quantity, then sends your quote.
- A $50 deposit holds your dateNon-refundable, and your order is confirmed once it's in.
- Pick up and celebrateFarmingville or South Huntington. Delivery is available for a small fee.
Request custom cookies
This is a request, not a final order. Jen will reach out by text to confirm details and pricing.
Recent sets
Fresh from the icing bag
Meet Jen
It started as a way to breathe.
I was home on maternity leave with my younger son and struggling with postpartum anxiety. Baking helped. I started watching videos on decorating with royal icing, and before long it was my favorite part of the day.
I made cookies for little celebrations at work and for family. Then people started asking if they could place orders. In May 2022, Frosted and Fabulous Cookies was born.
Today I bake for families, schools, businesses and event planners all over Long Island, and you can find me at a few holiday fairs each year. Every order still gets the same care as those first batches.
xo, Jen
Had Jen's cookies?
We're gathering our first reviews for this page. If you've ordered, we'd love to hear how they tasted.
Good to know
Questions, answered
What's the minimum order?
One dozen cookies for custom orders.
How much do custom cookies cost?
Cookies start at $5 each for the simplest designs, and the price goes up with detail. You'll get a quote after Jen talks through your design with you.
How far ahead should I order?
At least two weeks, subject to availability. Right now Jen is booking about six to eight weeks out, so the sooner the better.
How do I lock in my date?
A $50 non-refundable deposit confirms your order and reserves your date. No order is confirmed without it.
Where do I pick up?
Farmingville, or South Huntington on Saturday mornings. Pre-sales list their own pickup dates. The exact address is shared when your order is confirmed.
Do you deliver?
Yes, on request for a small fee, within Suffolk and Nassau Counties.
Do you ship?
No. New York cottage food laws don't allow shipping out of state, so all orders are local pickup or delivery.
How do I pay?
Zelle, Venmo or cash for custom orders. Credit cards aren't accepted at this time.
When do I pay for a pre-sale order?
Right after you order, you'll get an emailed invoice. Please pay by Zelle or Venmo within 24 hours to hold your order. Unpaid orders are released so someone else can have them.
What flavors do you offer?
One flavor, done really well: a vanilla sugar cookie decorated with royal icing.
How do pre-sales work?
A few times a year, around holidays and events, Jen opens a pre-sale with a handful of designs. Ordering opens two to four weeks before pickup and stays open for about a week. Join the pre-sale list above so you don't miss one.
Something sweet on your calendar?
Grab a set from the current pre-sale, or tell Jen about your event.